Skip to the shop floor

ProofOkay vs idmly

A side-by-side comparison built from both listings. Blank cells mean the company has not given that detail; we never guess.

ProofOkay compared with idmly
DetailProofOkay logo ProofOkayidmly logo idmly
What it doesProof approval software for anything that gets printed HTML design in. Editable InDesign out.
StageNot given Startup
FoundedNot given 2026
Based inNot given ZA
Pricing modelPaid Paid
Pricing$49 per month USD for unlimited users and unlimited proofs. 7 days free to look around with no card, then 14 days free trial. Free preview: two most detailed pages of any design, twice, no account needed. $49 lifetime license: unlimited full conversions, activate on up to 10 browsers or devices, works in browser and from AI agents over MCP.
Key features
  • Zoomable native file preview for PDF, Illustrator, EPS, Photoshop, TIFF, JPEG and PNG
  • Automatic print check at final print size for file size, image sharpness, vector status, CMYK/RGB color, bleed and fonts
  • Three approval options: Approve, Approve with changes, or Request changes
  • File uploads up to 300 MB with resumable uploads
  • No customer account or login required
  • Automatic reminders on custom schedule
  • Version tracking with message threads per proof
  • Customizable approval boxes and email wording
  • Converts HTML to native .idml files that open in Adobe InDesign
  • Real text frames with reflowable content
  • Named paragraph and character styles automatically created
  • Charts and tables as editable vector objects
  • Images placed and linked in a Links folder
  • Free preview of two most detailed pages without account
  • MCP server integration with Claude, Cursor, and other AI agents
  • 14-day fix-or-refund guarantee on licensed conversions
  • Supports output in Affinity Publisher as well as InDesign
  • Works with all CSS frameworks including Tailwind and Bootstrap
What makes it different
  • Customers zoom into native files and see fine print sharp instead of flattened JPEGs
  • Automatic print check at final print size catches issues before approval
  • One flat price for unlimited users and proofs instead of per-seat pricing
  • Made by the team behind PrinterFlo with upgrade path to full shop software
  • Deterministic conversion engine—no machine learning, same input always produces same output
  • Files deleted immediately after conversion—complete privacy, no storage or training
  • Native InDesign files, not PDFs—fully editable text, styles and charts
  • Direct integration with AI design tools through MCP protocol
Community votes00
DR (Domain Rating by Ahrefs)4 −1 (down) since last check6 no change since last check
Trust Flow (Majestic)04
Citation Flow (Majestic)024
Referring domains (Majestic)036

5 details filled in for both companies.

More alternatives to ProofOkay More alternatives to idmly

Support