Skip to the shop floor

CommentShark vs PigeonDM

A side-by-side comparison built from both listings. Blank cells mean the company has not given that detail; we never guess.

CommentShark compared with PigeonDM
DetailCommentShark logo CommentSharkPigeonDM logo PigeonDM
What it doesAI-powered YouTube comment automation for creators Instagram comment-to-DM automation that sends links and promo codes via direct message
StageNot given Startup
FoundedNot given 2026
Based inNot given FR
Pricing modelFreemium Freemium
PricingFree plan with 20 comment actions/month; Starter $19/month (500 actions, 10 rules); Creator $49/month (1,500 actions, 25 rules); Pro $139/month (5,000 actions, 50 rules); Custom pricing available. Free: $0 forever for 3 active posts with unlimited DMs. Pro: $15/month (or $150/year, 2 months free) for unlimited active posts and additional features.
Key features
  • AI-powered comment auto-reply with voice matching
  • AI comment classification and smart rules
  • 24/7 automated comment moderation
  • Spam, hate speech, and scam detection
  • Approval workflows for brand safety
  • YouTube comment search and filtering
  • Top commenters and engagement tracking
  • Blocked words list builder
  • Team collaboration with role-based access
  • Sentiment analysis and insights
  • One DM per person per post
  • Automatic public replies under comments
  • Complete activity log
  • Multiple trigger words per post (Pro plan)
  • Link click tracking (Pro plan)
  • No DM cap on either plan
  • Works on Posts, Reels and Carousels
  • Official Instagram API integration
  • Auto-reply to DMs and Story replies (Pro plan)
  • CSV export (Pro plan)
What makes it different
  • Review and approve replies before posting
  • AI learns your voice from past replies
  • 7-day money-back guarantee on first payment
  • Uses official YouTube API with OAuth 2.0 security
  • No Facebook Page required
  • No DM volume caps
  • Answers comments from before setup
  • Solo maker directly answering support
Free planNot given Not given
Open sourceNot given Not given
PlatformsNot given Not given
Public APINot given Not given
Community votes00
DR (Domain Rating by Ahrefs)23 +3 (up) since last checkNot checked yet no change since last check
Trust Flow (Majestic)40
Citation Flow (Majestic)2718
Referring domains (Majestic)513

5 details filled in for both companies.

More alternatives to CommentShark More alternatives to PigeonDM

Support